船舶融资租赁登记制度的功能主义突围与体系化重构兼论修订版《海商法》第8条第2款的修改

    A Functionalist Breakthrough in the Registration System of Ship Financial Leasing and Its Systematic Reconstruction: With a Discussion on the Amendment to Article 8 (2) of the Revised Maritime Code

    • 摘要: 船舶融资租赁登记长期面临法律规制缺位的困境,既存的光船租赁登记参照适用模式以及自贸区新型尝试模式都存在诸多结构性缺陷。《民法典》通过吸收功能主义精神,将融资租赁“功能化”为一类特殊的非典型担保物权、适用一般动产的登记对抗效力与优先顺位规则。现行船舶物权登记体系固守形式主义的权利公示体系,与《民法典》规定存在较为显著的制度张力,体现在公示内容、公示程序和对抗效力三个层面。船舶融资租赁登记制度应进行体系化构建,以出租人所有权为公示内容,在登记程序方面统合一般动产登记系统中的先进经验,并以船舶抵押权作为范本构建其登记对抗效力。2025年10月28日通过的修订版《海商法》第8条第2款引入船舶融资租赁登记的规定,但该款没有突破传统形式主义登记思路。建议后续通过修订《船舶登记条例》等下位法,构建更为完善的体系化船舶融资租赁登记制度,实现功能主义精神与海商法固有形式主义体系的有机融合。

       

      Abstract: The ship financial leasing registration has long been in the dilemma of absence of laws and regulations, and the existing mode of application of bareboat charter registration as reference and the new trial mode in the free trade zones have many structural defects. By absorbing the spirit of functionalism, the Civil Code specifies that finance leases are “functionalized” as special and atypical real rights for security, and apply to the registration confrontation effectiveness and priority rules applicable to general chattel mortgage. However, the existing ship-related property right registration system adheres to the formalistic right publicity system, and there is a relatively significant institutional tension between the current ship-related property right registration system and the provisions of the Civil Code, which is reflected in three aspects, i.e. the content to be publicized, the procedure of publicity and the effectiveness of confrontation. The ship financial leasing registration system shall be systematically constructed, and take the ownership of the lessor as the content to be publicized, integrate the advanced experience in the general chattel mortgage registration system in terms of registration procedures, and construct the effectiveness of registration confrontation based on the model of ship mortgage. At present, Paragraph 2 of Article 8 of the revised Maritime Law adopted on October 28, 2025 has introduced the provisions on the registration of ship financial leasing, but this paragraph does not break through the traditional formalist registration approach to registration. Therefore, it is suggested that an improved systematic registration system for ship financial leasing be established by revising the Regulations on Vessel Registration and other lower-level laws, to organically integrate the spirit of functionalism and the inherent formalism of the maritime law.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回